The Power of Nostalgia in Sag Harbor
In Sag Harbor, Colson Whitehead creatively uses the depths of nostalgia throughout the novel to explore the bittersweet memories of adolescence and the passage of time. Benji often looks back on his teenage summers in Sag Harbor during the 1980s, creating vivid memories of frozen moments like slurping down icees, biking through town, and hanging out with my friends. Whitehead’s use of detailed, sensory descriptions really brings the readers into memories and feel the emotions that Benji is feeling. “We were all there. It was where we mingled with who we had been and who we would be. Sharing space with our echoes out in the sun. The shy kid we used to be and were growing away from, the confident or hard-luck men we would become in our impending seasons, the elderly survivors we’d grow into if we were lucky, with gray stubble and green sun visors” (Whitehead 305). This is a point where Benji is on the brink of edge of adolescence and looks both forward and backward in time, dealing with the past, present, future versions of himself, not just remembering the “shy kid” he was, but imagining the “confident or hard-luck men” and “elderly survivors” he and his friends might one day become.
This is the creativity of the use of nostalgia that Whitehead uses, he doesn’t just use nostalgia to paint a rosy picture of the past, he also uses it to highlight the complexities and awkwardness of growing up. Benji’s memories often come with a self-aware, remembering family talks that shape his character growing up, slightly humorous commentary on his younger self’s insecurities, like worrying about his haircut or trying to fit in with his friends. This invites the readers to think about how we shape our past in memory. For example, Benji’s detailed recollections of working at the ice cream shop or attending bonfire parties capture the push-and-pull between wanting to be independent and still being tied to the safety of family and childhood.
Nostalgia in Sag Harbor serves as a lens through which Benji and the reader navigate identity, belonging, and change. Whitehead explains how these summer memories are not just about specific events but about the feelings attached to them—the sense of freedom, confusion, and yearning. By blending humor, tenderness, and sharp observation, Whitehead uses nostalgia not as a simple longing for the past but as a powerful tool to understand how our past shapes who we are today.
Works Cited
Whitehead, Colson. Sag Harbor. Doubleday, 2009.
Of all of these qualities Whitehead associates with the period of his life being evoked in this novel, "confusion" seems like the most prominent--there's no sense in which Ben, the adult narrator, would want to actually GO BACK to this time in his life and experience it all again. He depicts himself as painfully self-conscious, full of insecurity and self-doubt, desperate to maintain a front of coolness and masculinity, and not at all sure where he's headed in life. You articulate well the true nature of nostalgia in this novel--a sense of "pastness" itself, the sobering realization that the past has happened, you were there, it was real, and it's completely gone now, as are all of those people as they were at the time. Memory enables a kind of time-travel, and even if we are reminded of painful failures and awkward mishaps, there's something simply profound about gazing back through the years, *realizing* the true nature of time's slippage, and how all of us are so different than we were back then.
ReplyDelete